I Wish I’d Ended with More Razzmatazz

My presentation in class went pretty much as I’d hoped. I was pleased that my mother’s lessons to me as a child seemed to engage the class so well at the start of my presentation. I like to start my lessons with something dramatic like that whenever I can. (I generally avoid saying, “Today we’re going to….” or “Let’s pick up with….” or “OK class….” as the first words out of my mouth.) I was also pleased to hear the advice/lessons of our classmates who shared what their parents/guardians told them as children. I think we can all relate to the messages we were taught as kids. That’s why that seemed to me to be a great way to enter the world of Jamaica Kincaid’s “Girl”. Even though the girl in the story receives different advice than any of us probably had, we can all relate to basic premise of the story; we were all children once and our parents had things to say to us.

Technology is not my friend, so I wasn’t surprised at all that I couldn’t get my daughter’s boom box to play the song I had selected for the class. The song I did play was OK but the other one I had chosen was better for my purposes. (My selection was in English and Antigua is an English-speaking country. Also, the song I had selected was more clearly a Caribbean piece. It is by the same artist who did Hot, Hot, Hot.) But, I’m glad I marched on. I’ve learned that sometimes you just have to go on with the show when things don’t work as you’d hoped, especially when technology is concerned. Teachers always need Plan B, right?

One thing I wish I’d done differently is that I’d probably have told the class Cornell’s story as I would in an actual teaching situation (rather than just telling about the technique as I did). When teaching the lesson I would unfold Cornell’s story bit by bit with a storyteller’s flair. I’d tell my classmates that once there was a beautiful young African American boy named Cornell who grew up in a very poor neighborhood on the South Side of Chicago. I’d describe the neighborhood and how dangerous it was for Cornell to grow up there. I’d tell: how Cornell worked like crazy to earn a place in the science and tech magnet school, how he had one teacher at that school who identified Cornell’s talent and helped him apply to a predominantly white prep school in rural Massachusetts (to get him away from gangs in his neighborhood), how Cornell won a scholarship to that school, went there, and graduated with honors, how he won a scholarship at Carlton college, how he spent junior year in Germany and became fluent in German, how he put himself through law school after he graduated doing all sorts of jobs – DJ, temp work, modeling, working in an improv troupe, playing the trumpet, being featured in a national Coke commercial. (The campaign was “A Coke and a Smile” and Cornell was the smile.) I’d tell how Cornell went on to become a high-level consultant with the CIA. I’d tell Cornell’s whole story like that building and building before I’d reveal that the story is true and that Cornell is my husband. That way the story would have big impact, I think. (There’s my love of the dramatic again.)

I was perhaps too mindful of my 20-minute time limit and rushed through this part of the presentation. But, at least I do think my classmates got the gist of what I would be trying to accomplish in telling my husband’s remarkable story. Rule of thumb from my days on the seminar circuit: Start and end strong. I started my presentation strong but my ending could have had a lot more razzmatazz. Next time I’ll remember that. — Laura

7 thoughts on “I Wish I’d Ended with More Razzmatazz

  1. FrancoisGuidry

    I’ve never been particularly comfortable sharing personal stories with a class; nonetheless, I find that these stories can often mean the difference between a student connecting with literature or simply coasting through it. 
    Your story is a strong argument for bringing in contextual examples from outside the text. 

  2. laurelchinn

    Hey there, I wanted to tell you that I really liked your entre into the lesson.   I think that the tie in with your husband’s life and then the literature gave you a shot of approachability and made the lit. part real and accessible.  Good job.  lc

  3. Edith

    I think the real world examples were a great idea. One of the most often asked quesitons is why do we have to read this. I always try to have a "so what" in my classes. Your link to your own experiences ties that together.

    Edith

  4. Professor Sample

    Don’t sweat the technology stuff — the music ended up working great, and that roll-with-the-punches approach to last minute snags is one heck of an asset in the classroom.

    Seeing the boombox reminded me: some editions of our Norton Anthology (e.g. the "Short Edition" or the "Long Edition") come with an audio CD featuring authors reading their work, and among them is Jamaica Kincaid reading "Girl," and it’s really fantastic to hear.

  5. naomip

    Great job.  I went back and forth in my mind as you shared the advice you got from your mother, thinking first it was authentic, then hypothetical.  The part about the feet and the shoes and slouching really convinced me this could not have come from a "real" mother.  Great choice of examples.  As with all the presentations, the shortness of time that did not allow us to discuss the actual selections but only talk about what we would do if we had time was frustrating.  I would love to have had time to talk about the story.

  6. Sara

    I wanted to second what others said above. I genuinely enjoyed your lesson. Aside from the lesson plan, you have a very natural yet commanding speaking/presentation tone). Getting students to share advice dispensed by parents/ teachers/ any other authority figure is a superb way to get students more invested in the text. I also how you used the writing assignments to tie in point of view. Very enjoyable.

  7. jtemple1

    I thought your presentation was great and felt that the fact that you shared personal information made a huge difference in how I received the text and how I valued it.  It definitely brought to light the "so what?" of the text.  My most memorable teachers, and the ones for which I produced the most heartfelt and thoughtful work, were the ones who were accessible.  Writing can be a very personal experience and seeing you share your personal experiences would make me more at ease to take risks in my writing.

Comments are closed.